Yellowmouth Grouper versus Scamp


I'm down in Roatan and observed this fish being cleaned in 20' of water yesterday. The photos aren't great, but I'm trying to decide on its identity. I've read a past discussion on this subject back in 2010 on this forum and found it equally confusing. I've also viewed pics from the Smithsonian site, as well as Google Images. There are literally identical photos, that identify it as a Scamp or a Yellowmouth. I know the Scamp is more common along the continental coast, which is wear I am. I'm hoping that someone out there, might see something distinguishable in my pics, to come to a conclusion, as to what I observed.


Any chance it's a Tiger Grouper, as there was a large number in the area. I'm not sure if the yellow mouth, disqualifies it or not. Hoping someone will shed some light on this. Thx in advance.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Design by Joanne Kidd, development by Ben Weintraub